This beautifully restored 1840s farmhouse beside Mill Pond blends historic charm with modern comfort—open living spaces, screened porch, sunset views, and a separate studio for work or play in a peaceful West Tisbury setting.
Set beside the iconic Mill Pond in historic West Tisbury, 709 Old County Road—known as Mill Pond House—is a rare and beautifully restored 1840s farmhouse that blends timeless New England character with modern comfort. Thoughtfully renovated and richly detailed, this home offers a tranquil setting, scenic views, and a layout designed for relaxed Martha’s Vineyard living.
Inside, the home feels warm, welcoming, and effortlessly elegant. Original elements such as wide pine floors, classic columns, and antique accents create a sense of history, while updated systems—including brand-new mini-split air conditioning and modern climate control throughout—ensure contemporary comfort.
The first floor has been reimagined as an open, flowing space ideal for gathering. A cozy living area with a fireplace (decorative only) and a Smart TV opens into a fully equipped kitchen and a charming dining area with seating for eight. Just beyond, a screened porch extends the living space, offering a dining table, seating area, TV, and peaceful views across the landscaped yard, which gently slopes toward Mill Pond.
A comfortable first-floor bedroom with a half bath adds flexibility for guests who prefer main-level living.
Upstairs, the home features three additional bedrooms—king, queen, and twin—with two offering serene views of the pond. Two full bathrooms serve this level, with laundry conveniently located in one of them.
Adding to the home’s versatility is The Summer House—a converted barn now serving as a private studio space with a living area, half bath, bar sink, and WiFi. This space is ideal for remote work, creative pursuits, quiet reading, or simply having a separate retreat within the property.
Families will appreciate the full-size children’s playhouse, stocked with toys and games, while a fenced front yard provides added peace of mind for younger guests. Out back, the expansive lawn opens to sweeping pastoral views, often accompanied by unforgettable sunset skies that become part of the daily rhythm of this special home.
From its historic bones to its modern upgrades, from its screened porch to its pondside setting, Mill Pond House offers a vacation experience that feels authentic, calming, and deeply connected to the Vineyard’s heritage.
Whether you’re seeking slow mornings, long dinners, quiet afternoons, or space for both togetherness and solitude, 709 Old County Road delivers a truly distinctive Martha’s Vineyard stay—graceful, peaceful, and unforgettable.
