Oak Bluffs, MA 02557 35 New York Avenue

$3,500,000

Pending
35 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 135 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 235 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 3
20 more
35 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 435 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 535 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 635 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 735 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 835 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 935 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1035 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1135 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1235 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1335 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1435 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1535 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1635 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1735 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1835 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 1935 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 2035 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 2135 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 2235 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 2335 New York Avenue Oak Bluffs, MA - Image 24
Presented By: Emma Kennedy with Sandpiper Realty - 508-627-3737
  • MLS# 43989
  • 01/22/2026
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 7
  • Baths • 5
  • SQFT • 3,880

Home Details

An exceptional chance to own one of the few five-unit apartment buildings available on Martha’s Vineyard. Ideally located within a short walk to Oak Bluffs Center, the Harbor, ferry service, and public beaches, this property offers both convenience and strong income potential. The building includes five well-maintained apartments with a total of 7 bedrooms and has been thoughtfully renovated and consistently cared for over the years. There are two two-bedroom apartments and three one-bedroom apartments. With ample on-site parking, this property is easy to manage and highly attractive to year-round and seasonal tenants alike. Tenants-in-place notice required to be shown.
Presented By: Emma Kennedy with Sandpiper Realty - 508-627-3737

Interior Features for 35 New York Avenue

Bedrooms

Main Level Bedrooms3
Total Bedrooms7

Bathrooms

Half Baths

Other Interior Features

BasementBasement with shared Laundry
FlooringWood, Carpet
Furnished Y/NUnfurnished
Interior AmenitiesFloor 1: Two apartments - one bedroom and a two bedroom, Floor 2: Two apartments - one bedroom and a two bedroom, Floor 3: Studio apartment

General for 35 New York Avenue

AppliancesStove: Yes, Washer: Shared Laundry
Building Area UnitsSquare Feet
CityOak Bluffs
Full Baths5
HeatingOFHW
Lot Size Square Feet10370
MLS Area3
Property SubtypeMulti Family
Property TypeMulti Family
SewerSeptic Tank
Standard StatusPending
StatusPS
Tax Annual Amount8727.91
Tax Assessed Value1147100
Tax Lot298
Tax Year2025
TaxOtherAnnualAssessmentAmount581200
Total Rooms15
UtilitiesCbl
ViewNone
Year Built1884
ZoningR1

Exterior for 35 New York Avenue

Building Area Total3880
Exterior AmenitiesPubBch, Deck
Foundation DetailsBasement
Frontage TypeNone
Lot FeaturesYes
Lot Size Acres0.238
Lot Size Area0.238
Parking FeaturesYes
Water SourceTown

Additional Details

Price History

Nolan Lavoie

REALTOR®, Rental Specialist
Price $3,500,000
MLS#43989
List Date 01/22/2026
Property Type Multi-Family
Phone 774.563.2459
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 35 New York Avenue

Ask A Question