West Tisbury, MA 02535104 Old Herring Creek Road

An extraordinary opportunity to own one of the Cape’s most distinctive waterfront properties, this exceptional 5.3-acre estate parcel combines remarkable natural beauty, complete privacy, and an unparalleled coastal setting. At its heart is a beautifully renovated four-bedroom beach cottage, thoughtfully updated with modern amenities while preserving the character and intimacy of a classic seaside retreat. From virtually every room, expansive water views create a seamless connection to the surrounding landscape. The property’s exceptional topography and scale are among its defining features. A meandering private path descends naturally through the expansive grounds, leading to approximately 450 feet of private sandy beachfront, an extraordinary stretch of shoreline offering a rare sense of seclusion and direct access to the water. Set within a conservation-minded private enclave, the property enjoys an atmosphere of discretion and exclusivity. Its distinguished setting is further enhanced by its adjacency to the historic Mohu estate, once associated with Katharine Graham, adding a notable sense of place and provenance. Rarely does a property offer this combination of significant acreage, extraordinary waterfront, private beach, architectural charm, and an incomparable setting. A truly exceptional coastal retreat and an opportunity of remarkable scarcity.